Photography Mentoring and Coaching: Two Sides of the Same Coin?
By Dr Greg McMillan GMAPS EFIAP EPSA BPSA Hon FAPS
Photography as a Serious Hobby
Mentoring and coaching in photography are topics that come up from time to time. In my professional role I collaborated with a friend and colleague on an article on coaching and mentoring. Given my interest in photography and the roles I often undertake in the broader photographic community, I thought I would share a few thoughts on how these concepts might apply to photography.
Becoming a better photographer involves much more than mastering equipment and technical skills. It requires developing an understanding of light, composition, perspective and visual storytelling. It also involves learning to see differently, making creative decisions and developing an individual photographic voice.
While their origins and approaches may differ, mentoring and coaching have a potentially important place in the helping a photographer develop their knowledge, skills and the person as a ‘photographer’. There are different ways of understanding the distinction between coaching and mentoring; however, the following provides one perspective.
Perhaps the fundamental question is whether mentoring and coaching are really different, or whether they are simply two sides of the same coin, with the distinction depending largely on how we define and apply them.
A mentor is generally considered to be an experienced and trusted adviser who shares knowledge, experience and guidance to support the development of another person.
Coaching, traditionally associated with sport, has evolved into a broader approach to helping individuals establish goals, explore possibilities and find their own solutions to challenges.
So, how might they differ in a photographic context?
Arguably a coaching has a sharper focus on achieving outcomes based on identified goals. The process is more reliant on asking “good questions” and helping the photographer explore the best outcomes for themselves.
Mentoring is generally broader in nature; more reliant on experiential conversations between photographer and mentor and has an emphasis on learning from other people’s experience.
For example, rather than suggesting how an image might be improved, a coach might ask:
- What attracted you to this subject?
- What were you hoping to communicate?
- Why did you choose this composition or perspective?
- What might you do differently next time?
While a mentor may well guide the individual to exploring other opportunities to provide the photographer with a range of different experiences.
Another distinction sometimes made is that coaching tends to have a more defined focus, helping someone work towards a particular photographic goal. Mentoring, on the other hand, may take a broader view, supporting the photographer’s ongoing development over time.
Of course, the two approaches often overlap. A good mentor will ask questions and encourage reflection, just as a coach may draw on their own photographic experience to offer guidance; however, both are about helping someone get more out of their photography.
What makes an effective photographic mentor or coach?
Regardless of the approach, some principles are important to an effective relationship:
- Build trust and rapport. Photographers need to feel comfortable sharing their work, discussing challenges and receiving constructive feedback. Ethical, social and cultural issues are important elements to consider as these underpin confidence and trust between individuals.
- Establish clear expectations. Those involved should understand the purpose of the relationship, what they hope to achieve and the time and emotional commitment involved.
- Encourage independent thinking. The objective is to develop confidence and capability, not create photographers who simply replicate someone else’s style or approach.
- Be adaptable. Sometimes a photographer needs technical guidance: at other times, they need someone to challenge their thinking, ask questions or simply provide encouragement.
Underpinning these principles is an important consideration: an experienced photographer might be an excellent photographer but not necessarily an effective mentor or coach. Technical expertise does not automatically translate into the ability to support someone else’s development.
If you are interested in becoming an effective mentor or coach, take the time to develop the knowledge and skills required for the role, particularly in areas that may not already be among your strengths. If you are seeking a mentor or coach, look beyond their technical skills or photographic achievements. Consider their ability to communicate, listen, encourage and support your development as a photographer.
It is also important to avoid creating dependency. For example, an experienced photographer might initially provide useful feedback and guidance, but over time the less experienced photographer may rely on them for too many photographic decisions.
Without clear expectations, development goals and boundaries, a supportive relationship can unintentionally become one of dependency rather than independence. The aim should always be to help photographers become more capable and confident in making their own decisions.
To summarise, mentoring and coaching are arguably two sides of the same coin. Both seek to support the development of another photographer, although their approaches may differ.
Perhaps the important question is not whether we call ourselves a mentor or a coach, but whether we understand what the photographer needs and how best to support their development.
Importantly, the objective should be much bigger than helping someone take technically better photographs. It should be about encouraging photographers to see differently, think more critically, experiment with confidence and develop their own creative voice.
After all, the aim is not to create another photographer who takes photographs like us, but to help someone become the photographer they want to be.